Opened 9 years ago

Closed 8 years ago

#1575 closed proposed-project (wontfix)

Rewrite xmonad in Java

Reported by: Roman Cheplyaka Owned by: Roman Cheplyaka
Priority: bad Keywords:
Cc: Difficulty: 3 people Summer
Mentor: not-accepted Topic: misc


There are many problems with first-class functions -- they cannot be compared for equality, serialized etc. This makes a lot of inconveniences for xmonad developers, some of these problems were discussed on the mailing list recently. I think the most obvious solution is to rewrite xmonad in a language which does not support first-order functions. Although it's not trivial to find such language, I think I did -- something called Java.

Now, you ask, why do I propose this project for Well, there's no such mentoring organization as (or even Besides, there's apparent profit for the Haskell community. It is well-known that xmonad serves as the source of many new Haskellers. First they search for a usable window manager, then they find one and must learn a whole language to configure it, then they like the language and start use it. Surely this doesn't help avoiding success at all cost.

xmonad users will also benefit from such rewrite. I haven't decided yet whether new xmonad config will be in Java itself or in XML. In the first case, we have an ability to use a lot of design patterns there, which makes it easier for users to get familiar with configuration (because, you know, today everyone knows design patterns). In the second case we don't need a Java compiler to be installed, and since XML is standard there are many editors there which make XML editing easy and straightforward. But in either case it will be more readable than current conglomeration of combinators.

Finally, I don't think we need that frightening name "xmonad" any more. How about "xfactoryfactory"?

Attachments (1)

haskell-mascot.jpg (4.9 KB) - added by Roman Cheplyaka 9 years ago.
Haskell mascot

Download all attachments as: .zip

Change History (3)

Changed 9 years ago by Roman Cheplyaka

Attachment: haskell-mascot.jpg added

Haskell mascot

comment:1 Changed 8 years ago by Johan Tibell

Priority: goodbad

comment:2 Changed 8 years ago by dons

Resolution: wontfix
Status: newclosed

Too old.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.