|Version 6 (modified by AntC, 4 years ago) (diff)|
One might imagine that it would be a simple matter to have a type-level function
type family Equal a b :: Bool
so that (Equal t1 t2) was True if t1=t2 and False otherwise. But it isn't. You can do it for a fixed collection of types thus:
type instance Equal a a = True type instance Equal Int Bool = False type instance Equal Bool Int = False
but this obviously gets stupid as you add more types. Nor can you write
type instance Equal a a = True type instance Equal a b = False
because System FC (rightly) prohibits overlapping family instances.
What to do about it
So the deficiency is in System FC, and it seems fundamental. We've been working on an extension to System FC, with a corresponding source-language extension, that does allow overlapping type families, with care. You would write something like this:
type instance where Equal a a = True Equal a b = False
This wiki page is a stub:
- See this Github repo for a Latex draft of the design
- Here is a cached pdf of the current state
- We'll use GHC branch ghc-axioms for development work.
Status (Jan 12): the groundwork is done, in HEAD; mainly making CoAxiom a more fundamental data type. Not yet started on the details.
Discussion Page added May 2012, for comment/suggestions/requests for clarification/alternative solutions, to explore the design space.
- We'll need some concrete syntax for the discussion, so we'll follow the cached pdf, but note that the syntax there is not final.