Version 48 (modified by dreixel, 2 years ago) (diff)


Support for generic programming

GHC includes a new (in 2010) mechanism to let you write generic functions. It is described in paper A generic deriving mechanism for Haskell. This page sketches the specifics of the implementation; we assume you have read the paper. The HaskellWiki page gives a more general overview.

This mechanism replaces the previous generic classes implementation. What we describe until the "Kind polymorphic overhaul" section is implemented and released in GHC 7.0.1.

Main components

  • TcDeriv.tcDeriving now allows deriving Generic instances.
  • The representation types and core functionality of the library live on GHC.Generics (on the ghc-prim package).
  • Many names have been added as known in prelude/PrelNames
  • Most of the code generation is handled by types/Generics

Things that have been removed

  • All of the generic classes stuff. In particular, the following have been removed:
    • hasGenerics field from TyCon;
    • HsNumTy constructor from HsType;
    • TypePat constructor from Pat.
  • The -XGenerics flag is now deprecated.

What already works

  • Generic instances can be derived when -XDeriveGeneric is enabled.
  • The default keyword can used for generic default method signatures when -XDefaultSignatures is enabled.
  • Generic defaults are properly instantiated when giving an instance without defining the generic default method.
  • Base types like [], Maybe, tuples, come with Generic instances.

To be done

  • Derive Generic1 instances


  • Tests are available under the generics directory of the testsuite.

Kind polymorphic overhaul

With the new -XPolyKinds functionality we can make the support for generic programming better typed. The basic idea is to define the universe codes (M1, :+:, etc.) as constructors of a datatype. Promotion then lifts these constructors to types, which we can use as before, only that now we have them all classified under a new kind:

{-# LANGUAGE TypeOperators              #-}
{-# LANGUAGE GADTs                      #-}
{-# LANGUAGE TypeFamilies               #-}
{-# LANGUAGE ScopedTypeVariables        #-}
{-# LANGUAGE FlexibleContexts           #-}
{-# LANGUAGE FlexibleInstances          #-}
{-# LANGUAGE PolyKinds                  #-}
{-# LANGUAGE DefaultSignatures          #-}
{-# LANGUAGE NoImplicitPrelude          #-}

module GHC.NewGenerics where

import Prelude hiding (Functor(..), Show(..)) -- we'll redefine them
import qualified Prelude as P (Show(..))

Generic representation universe

m is the only real parameter here. f and x are there because we can't write kinds directly, since Universe is also a datatype (even if we're only interested in its promoted version). So we pass f and x only to set them to * -> * and *, respectively, in Interprt. m is different: it stands for the kind of metadata representation types, and we really want to be polymorphic over that, since each user datatype will introduce a new metadata kind.

data Universe f x m = 
    -- Void (used for datatypes without constructors)
    -- Unit
  | UU
  -- The parameter
  | PAR
  -- Recursion into a type of kind * -> *
  | REC f
  -- Constants (either other parameters or recursion into types of kind *)
  | KK Constant x
  -- Metadata
  | MM MetaData m (Universe f x m)
  -- Sum, product, composition
  | Universe f x m :++: Universe f x m
  | Universe f x m :**: Universe f x m
  | f :..: Universe f x m
  -- Note that we always compose a concrete type on the left (like []) with
  -- a generic representation on the right

infixr 5 :++:
infixr 6 :**:
infixr 6 :*:
infixr 7 :..:

-- Some shortcuts
data MetaData = CC | DD | SS
data Constant = PP | RR

data ConstantV (c :: Constant) where
  P :: ConstantV PP
  R :: ConstantV RR
data MetaDataV (m :: MetaData) where
  C :: MetaDataV CC
  D :: MetaDataV DD
  S :: MetaDataV SS

Universe interpretation

As promised, we set f to * -> * and x to *. Unfortunately we don't have explicit kind variable annotations yet, so we cannot leave m polymorphic! So this code doesn't compile:

data Interprt :: Universe (* -> *) * m -> * -> * where

  -- No interpretation for VV, as it shouldn't map to any value
  -- Unit
  U1     :: Interprt UU p
  -- The parameter
  Par1   :: p -> Interprt PAR p
  -- Recursion into a type of kind * -> *
  Rec1   :: r p -> Interprt (REC r) p
  -- Constants
  K1     :: x -> Interprt (KK c x) p
  -- Constants shortcuts
  Par0   :: x -> Interprt (KK PP x) p
  Rec0   :: x -> Interprt (KK RR x) p
  -- Metadata
  M1     :: Interprt x p -> Interprt (MM m c x) p
  -- Metadata shortcuts
  D1     :: Interprt x p -> Interprt (MM DD c x) p
  C1     :: Interprt x p -> Interprt (MM CC c x) p
  S1     :: Interprt x p -> Interprt (MM SS c x) p
  -- Sum, product, and composition
  L1     :: Interprt a r -> Interprt (a :++: b) r
  R1     :: Interprt b r -> Interprt (a :++: b) r
  (:*:)  :: Interprt a r -> Interprt b r -> Interprt (a :**: b) r
  Comp1  :: f (Interprt g r) -> Interprt (f :..: g) r


As an aside, note that we have to come up with names like UU and KK for the Universe even though we really just wanted to use U1 and K1, like before. Then we would have a type and a constructor with the same name, but that's ok. However, Universe defines both a type (with constructors) and a kind (with types). So if we were to use U1 in the Universe constructors, then we could no longer use that name in the Interprt constructors. It's a bit annoying, because we are never really interested in the type Universe and its constructors: we're only interested in its promoted variant. This is a slight annoyance of automatic promotion: when you define a "singleton type" (like our GADT Interprt for Universe) you cannot reuse the constructor names.

Metadata representation

data Proxy d = Proxy -- kind polymorphic

-- Meta data classes
class Datatype d where
  -- The name of the datatype, fully qualified
  datatypeName :: Proxy d -> String

There's more of these, but they don't add any new concerns.

Conversion between user datatypes and generic representation

-- Representable types of kind *
class Generic a where
  type Rep a :: Universe (* -> *) * m
  from :: a -> Interprt (Rep a) x
  to   :: Interprt (Rep a) x -> a
-- Representable types of kind * -> *
class Generic1 (f :: * -> *) where
  type Rep1 f :: Universe (* -> *) * m
  from1  :: f a -> Interprt (Rep1 f) a
  to1    :: Interprt (Rep1 f) a -> f a

Example generic function: fmap (kind * -> *)

User-visible class, exported:

class Functor (f :: * -> *) where
  fmap :: (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
  default fmap :: (Generic1 f, GFunctor (Rep1 f)) => (a -> b) -> f a -> f b
  fmap f = to1 . gfmap f . from1  

Defined by the generic programmer, not exported:

class GFunctor (f :: Universe (* -> *) * m) where
  gfmap :: (a -> b) -> Interprt f a -> Interprt f b
instance GFunctor UU where
  gfmap _ U1 = U1
instance GFunctor PAR where
  gfmap f (Par1 a) = Par1 (f a)

instance GFunctor (KK i c) where
  gfmap _ (K1 a) = K1 a

instance (Functor f) => GFunctor (REC f) where
  gfmap f (Rec1 a) = Rec1 (fmap f a)

instance (GFunctor f) => GFunctor (MM m c f) where
  gfmap f (M1 a) = M1 (gfmap f a)

instance (GFunctor f, GFunctor g) => GFunctor (f :++: g) where
  gfmap f (L1 a) = L1 (gfmap f a)
  gfmap f (R1 a) = R1 (gfmap f a)

instance (GFunctor f, GFunctor g) => GFunctor (f :**: g) where
  gfmap f (a :*: b) = gfmap f a :*: gfmap f b

instance (Functor f, GFunctor g) => GFunctor (f :..: g) where
  gfmap f (Comp1 x) = Comp1 (fmap (gfmap f) x)

Example generic function: show (kind *, uses metadata)

User-visible class, exported:

class Show (a :: *) where
  show :: a -> String
  default show :: (Generic a, GShow (Rep a)) => a -> String
  show = gshow . from

Defined by the generic programmer, not exported:

class GShow (f :: Universe (* -> *) * m) where
  gshow :: Interprt f x -> String
instance GShow UU where
  gshow U1 = ""
instance (P.Show c) => GShow (KK i c) where
  gshow (K1 a) = a
instance (Datatype c, GShow f) => GShow (MM DD c f) where
  gshow (M1 x) = datatypeName (Proxy :: Proxy c) ++ " " ++ gshow x

The other cases do not add any further complexity.

Example datatype encoding: lists (derived by the compiler)

instance Generic [a] where
  type Rep [a] = MM DD DList 
                   (MM CC DList_Nil UU :++: 
                    MM CC DList_Cons (KK PP a :**: KK RR [a]))

  from [] = D1 (L1 (C1 U1))
  from (h:t) = D1 (R1 (C1 (Par0 h :*: Rec0 t)))
  to (D1 (L1 (C1 U1))) = []
  to (D1 (R1 (C1 (Par0 h :*: Rec0 t)))) = h:t
-- Metadata
data List_Meta = DList | DList_Nil | DList_Cons

Note that we use only one datatype; more correct would be to use 3, one for DList, another for the constructors, and yet another for the selectors (or maybe even n datatypes for the selectors, one for each constructor?) But we don't do that because Universe is polymorphic only over m, so a single metadata representation type. If we want a more fine-grained distinction then we would need more parameters in Universe, and also to split the MM case.

instance Datatype DList where datatypeName _ = "[]"


Even better would be to index the metadata representation types over the type they refer to. Something like:

  data family MetaTypes a -- kind polymorphic
  data instance MetaTypes [] = DList | DList_Nil | DList_Cons

But now we are basically asking for promotion of data families, since we want to use promoted DList. Also, the case for MM in Universe would then be something like:

  | MM MetaData (MetaTypes m) (Universe f x m)

But I'm not entirely sure about this.