Changes between Version 3 and Version 4 of Ticket #311


Ignore:
Timestamp:
Sep 11, 2007 7:03:23 AM (7 years ago)
Author:
simonpj
Comment:

Comment from Benedict Huber

I've been struggling using FFI bindings to libraries which rely on the GNU Mp Bignum library (gmp) - this is apparently a well known problem (#311, [wiki:ReplacingGMPNotes). I do rely on using such libraries, and so started to get it work on MacOsX; no solution was close to being satisfactory however, so I'd like to ask for some advice.

Those two options worked to some extend:

  • Create or modify the library in question, so gmp is statically linked and its symbols are hidden. When source code is available, this is relatively easy, altough it requires modification of the build process (which can be a hassle). If a static "ar" archive is available, it is cumbersome (at least on Mac Os X I ran into a lot of troubles using nmedit), but possible. Furthermore, the resulting libraries are bloated, as each of them contains a copy of the GMP; left alone portability issues.
  • As suggested an earlier comment, I tried switching the allocator functions when switching to FFI. It worked, but not in GHCi; also, doing it manually is a lot of work, because, as far as I could figure out, it is neccessary to write a wrapper function for every C-function (indirectly) using the gmp.

Furthermore, most of the libraries expose gmp datatypes (mpz_t,mpq_t) in their API. I currently use a little haskell module working on GHC.Exts, but that's propably not a good option from a maintainer's point of view. There are certainly other possibilities, but I couldn't find one which is both maintainable and portable.

I would be very grateful for any advice, or some information on plans for resolving ticket #311. There are some great libraries (like the Parma Polyhedral Library, to pick an example) out there using gmp, and it would be nice if writing bindings to those libs could be simplified.

Thanks, Benedikt Huber

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #311 – Description

    v3 v4  
    1 {{{ 
    2 Simon M, 
    3  
    41I assume ghc allocates the lumps of gmp integers still 
    52on ghc's heap, making it impossible (or very awkward) 
     
    118Thanks, 
    129Axel. 
    13  
    14 }}}[]